The woman is never identified by name. She doesn’t speak a word.
She is simply referred to as “a woman in the city, who was a sinner.”
While the exact nature of her sin is never explicitly stated, it has generally been assumed that it was “notorious sexual activity, prostitution”.[i]
The narrative does not provide specifics about the exact timing and location of the dinner party. It can only be inferred that the dinner occurred sometime, “during [Jesus’] ministry up north in Galilee”.[ii]
The host’s name is provided. But exactly which Simon he was remains unclear because the name Simon was “as common in the ancient world as ‘Smith’ is in our phone book”.[iii]
None of the guests who are attending the banquet are named. They are simply referred to as “those who were at the table.”
The crowd of onlookers who would have typically entered into the open courtyard to listen to the Teacher and guests’ discourse are not even referenced.[iv]
Jesus is the only person specifically identified in the passage entitled, “A Sinful Woman Forgiven” (Luke 7:36-50).
While there is such depth and breadth of meaning to be drawn from this passage, a primary focus has historically been on the “emotional extravagance of the woman’s actions.”[v] This stems from most traditional interpretations that have tended to focus on the fact that she was a woman, a sinner, and a social outcast who unreservedly engaged in what was deemed excessive behaviour.
Somewhat less focused on is how her courageous actions embodied love.
Intent on reaching Jesus she had bravely pushed past the on-lookers in the courtyard. She did not acknowledge the crowd, the guests, or the self-righteous host, some of whom may very well have been her former lovers.[vi]
Love and a yearning to worship Jesus outweighed the evident disdain and rejection of those in the room.
As she knelt down by Jesus she openly wept. She washed his feet with her tears, gently dried them with her unbound hair, kissed them, and then anointed them with expensive oil. His willingness to forgive her sins had overwhelmed her.
Meanwhile, Simon, who prided himself as being righteous and without sin, was highly critical of the woman and her demonstrative behaviour. After all, she was widely known throughout the community as being immoral and impure.
As Simon watched he “silently impugns the woman’s character and questions Jesus” and condemned him for allowing the unclean woman to touch him.[vii]
Simon concluded that “If this man were a prophet, he would know who is touching him and what kind of woman she is – that she is a sinner” (Luke 7:39).
Simon remained fixated on her past behaviour. And judged her to be unclean.
Jesus perceived the state of her heart.
“Jesus receives her ministrations and recognizes them as indicative of a profoundly altered attitude. Her act of devotion represents her best effort to express her newly awakened response to God’s grace. Whether her past actions have been the result of lust, need, manipulation or defiance, she has been transformed by the power of divine love.”[viii]
Jesus celebrated her transformation. Recognizing how her love flowed out of her profound gratitude.
As he turned to face her he declared that her sins were forgiven.[ix]
Jesus also perceived the state of Simon’s heart.
A heart hardened by sins of self-righteousness, criticism and condemnation.
Jesus confronts Simon about his lack of hospitality and grace, condemning his judgmental attitude.[x] But Simon’s heart remains hard and unyielding.
In the end, the narrative reveals that “love, is both the cause and result or sign of divine forgiveness. The woman embodies that love.”[xi]
So, I wonder. Which of the people in this narrative – the onlooker, invited guest, Simon, the woman or Jesus – am I most like? Are you most like?
Honestly, I see a bit of my self in each of them.
I can be the onlooker. Silent. Watching. Letting things unfold.
I can be one the invited guests and part of the inner group. Also silent. Also watching.
I can be Simon. The self-righteous sinner who can be quick to criticize and judge others. Who can struggle to offer and hold sufficient grace and forgiveness. Often lacking in sincere repentance. Being so distracted by my own sinful thoughts that I can miss seeing Jesus, even when he is right in front of me.
I am the woman. Also a sinner. Whose heart is gradually being transformed. So overwhelmed by Jesus’ generous love that I can weep for the pure joy of it. And as his lavish grace washes through and over me – my heart explodes with praise.
And it is in these moments, where Jesus’ divine love and grace empowers me that I am awakened, enabled to embody his love in action.
Photo credits: Rubens’ Feast of Simon the Pharisee
Hanny Naibah, Woman hands up lifted, Unsplash
Endnotes:
[i] Carol A. Newsom and Sharon H. Ringe, and Jacqueline E. Lapsley. Womens Bible Commentary: Revised and Updated. Louisville, Ky: Westminster John Knox Press, 2012, 374.[ii] Ibid, 374.
[iii] Robert Deffinbaugh. “Wordless Worship of an Unnamed Woman (Luke 7:36-50).” Bible.org23 (June 22, 2004). Accessed October 09, 2018. https://bible.org/seriespage/23-wordless-worship-unnamed-woman-luke-736-5., 1.
[iv] Ibid, 1.
[v] Newsom, et al, 505.
[vi] Catherine Clark Kroeger & Mary J. Evans (Eds.). The IVP Women’s Bible Commentary. Downers Grove, Illinois: Intervarsity Press, 2002, 570.
[vii] Carol Meyers, Toni Craven, and Ross S. Kraemer (Eds.) Women in scripture: A dictionary of named and unnamed women in the Hebrew Bible, the apocryphal / deuterocanonical books and the New Testament. Grand Rapids, Mich: Eerdmans, 2000, 440.
[viii] Kroeger, 570.
[ix] Meyers, et al, 440.
[x] Kroeger, 570.
[xi] Newsom, et al., 505.
Bob HaywardOctober 17, 2018 7:45 am
Anne – this is a truly powerful insight – thank for the way that you have peeled back the layers of truth in this short verse.
I, like you, feel alliance with each of the characters at times while desiring to be more like Jesus more often
Anne Mackie-MorelliOctober 18, 2018 12:39 am
Bob, while I feel an affinity with each of the characters, I too desire to become more and more like Jesus. Blessings.
Chloe FlanaganOctober 17, 2018 10:46 am
Great post! I love this story. How true that we can identify with each figure in the story. When we are transformed my Christ’s love, we shouldn’t hesitate to reflect it and seek it out in others.
Anne Mackie-MorelliOctober 18, 2018 12:38 am
Chloe, thanks for your comments. I love this story too! I agree, I think most of us will be able to identify with each figure in the narrative. And what a great comment about how when we are transformed by Christ’s grace, forgiveness and abundant love – it should move us to courageously reflect it and live in out. Blessings, and thanks for visiting The Stones Call.
CrystalOctober 17, 2018 3:52 pm
This is a movement for God, by all means, it touches the soul of the ones who will truly understand. I pray that you continue this movement in jesuse name to help all sinners know that don’t wait too late to ask for gods forgives. I enjoyed the read.
Anne Mackie-MorelliOctober 18, 2018 12:35 am
Crystal, thanks for visiting The Stones Call and for commenting. Yes, God’s grace and forgiveness does touch our souls and creates an overflow or movement of profound gratitude and love. Blessings.
RobertOctober 17, 2018 10:58 pm
Thanks for sharing this. I’m glad you drew out certain details and also how you didn’t associate this passage with similar anointing passages in Matthew, Mark and John’s gospel where the character and theological emphasis is entirely different. I’ve actually written a post before about the differences between these 4 anointings if you’re interested to read.
I can also see a bit of myself in both of these figures in this passage. It’s funny how even though I know I’m a sinner in need of forgiveness, I can still be judgmental like Simon the pharisee. It’s something we can all struggle with.
Anne Mackie-MorelliOctober 18, 2018 12:33 am
Robert, I always appreciate your insightful comments. As you noted there are passages in the Matthew, Mark, and John which appear similar but are different. Interesting that you noticed how I just chose to focus on the one passage rather than associate them with one another. This was an intentional choice because I wanted to just dial into the way Luke wrote and presented this narrative. In my research I noticed the difference between the anointings in the four different passages, but I would always be interested in reading your post and your perspectives. Interesting that you also see yourself in each of these figures. As I wrote the article I wondered if that might be one reason why everyone in the narrative remains unnamed – so that her or his actions and thoughts become more generic and openly representative of all humankind, not just that one person. And yes, I totally agree that it is so easy to slip into judgment, just like Simon, even when I know I am being a sinner who is sinning as I criticizing another sinner! Thanks for your comments.
RobertOctober 24, 2018 2:45 pm
Thanks for elaborating further on your post Anne. I do think that the passages in the gospels, even when a person is named, have enough universal relevance that we can apply the principles to ourselves. I find myself identifying with almost everyone that Jesus either encounters or speaks about in a parable. They all describe the human condition and our need for God in some way.
My post comparing the various anointings in the gospels is here: https://drawingontheword.com/mary-of-bethany-sinful-woman-anointed/
It’s fairly detailed, but I was trying to be thorough because I know that some Christians do simply give it only a superficial reading and conclude they are the same passage, even when it’s quite clear that Luke’s is really quite different.
Anne Mackie-MorelliOctober 24, 2018 11:37 pm
Robert, I totally agree that there is a universal relevance to almost every character in Scripture, in one way or another. But I just found it interesting that within a whole passage not one person is named, other than Jesus. For me, the omission of names and of a specific location suggests it is noteworthy. Perhaps to reinforce the idea of universal relevance. I read your post focusing on the comparison between the passages and really appreciated your insights. I totally agree that Luke’s is focusing on a different event. As always, I appreciate our conversations! Thanks for commenting.
Kathleen BaileyOctober 18, 2018 3:41 pm
This was a beautiful post about that story in the Bible, thank you for sharing. I think we are all, all of those people at one time or another.
Anne Mackie-MorelliOctober 18, 2018 4:56 pm
Kathleen, thanks for dropping by The Stones Call and for your encouraging comment. Yes, I agree that we are all of these people in one way or another, at one time or another. Although, I do think we can easily deceive ourselves into thinking we are more like the woman or Jesus even when, in our own self-righteousness, we can so easily slip into Simon-like behaviour and start concentrating on others and their sins rather than keeping our eyes focused on our own path and relationship with Jesus. The woman inspires me because her focus on Jesus does not waver. Although she must have been aware of what the guests, servers, onlookers, Simon and the community thought of her she never got distracted by their opinions and attitudes. I pray that I can become transformed to be more and more like the woman who embodied such love and worshipped Jesus with such focused devotion. Blessings!
JerraleaOctober 21, 2018 9:39 pm
I think for long-time believers it is very easy to slip into the judgmental attitude of Simon – at least it is for me. I pray for fresh eyes to see Jesus as He really is. I think if granted this wish, it would be prompt loving extravagantly as this woman did!
Anne Mackie-MorelliOctober 22, 2018 1:31 am
Jerralea, Yes, I think you make such a great point about how easy it is for long time believers to slip into Simon-like, judgemental attitudes about others. Praying for seeing Jesus clearing and for the Holy Spirit to wash us afresh will help us see Jesus clearly when He is in front of us and to exude His amazing grace and love into the world around us. I too pray that I can love as extravagantly as this woman did! Thanks for commenting. Blessings.
Andrew @ TheRoadToEmmaus.caOctober 24, 2018 2:16 pm
This post was written so well! I’ve always loved this story. I pray that I too would love and worship Jesus extravagantly, He is worthy of all I have. Bless you!
Anne Mackie-MorelliOctober 24, 2018 11:38 pm
Thank you so much for your encouraging comments Andrew! I always appreciate hearing from you! Thanks for visiting.
Janene EldredApril 17, 2019 12:12 pm
I love your interpretation of this story! You made it become so real and emotional. It is easy to see it as just a “woman who washed Jesus feet with her tears.” Instead you went inside what was going on in the emotions and attitudes people in the room displayed. Thank you, and God bless you!
Anne Mackie MorelliApril 17, 2019 2:57 pm
Janene, thanks for your encouraging comments! I really enjoyed spending time researching and studying this woman and her narrative. A beautiful narrative and such a faithful, courageous woman. Thanks for visiting The Stones Call! Blessings.
AlphaApril 17, 2019 1:51 pm
Another great read from you. I really to bookmark your blog and read more of you post over the weekend.
Anne Mackie MorelliApril 17, 2019 2:58 pm
Alpha, I am delighted you enjoyed the post and will return to read more of them! Thanks for commenting and for visiting The Stones Call.
EricApril 20, 2019 11:25 am
Nicely written post. Very thorough and thought out. Thought provoking in which we can all relate in one aspect or another.
Anne Mackie MorelliApril 20, 2019 4:39 pm
Eric, thanks for your encouragement. Yes, I totally agree thatthere are so many rich aspects to this narrative that we can all relate to one way or another. Blessings.
DONNA MILLERApril 20, 2019 1:12 pm
I love your post Anne! And I love this particular story in the Bible. I remember when I first became a Christian, the first time I read this story I thought oh wow, this women was forgiven for MANY sins. Then Jesus opened my eyes that we all have many sins. She loves much because she was so aware how much she needed Jesus and what He has done for her. When we think contrary and believe we don’t have as many sins to be forgiven, we will not love much because we haven’t fully received Jesus’ gift of forgiveness. ❤
Anne Mackie MorelliApril 20, 2019 4:38 pm
Donna, thank you so much for your encouraging comments and for visiting The Stones Call. I am delighted that you enjoyed this post and that it resonated with you. I too find it reassuring to rest in the certainty that though Jesus sees us, in all our messiness, he still loves us. And yes, our love and worship is a response to his abundant love and grace and forgiveness.
Julie PlagensApril 21, 2019 7:32 pm
This is one of my favorite stories. I can see myself in many of the characters. Hopefully, I identify with Jesus the most. Great writing.
Anne Mackie MorelliApril 22, 2019 9:48 am
Julie, while I too can identify with parts of each character I also pray that I increasingly become more identified with Jesus’ character and nature. Thanks for your encouraging comments.